The paradox of Shaul Hamelech - the most pious of men who was prone to cruelty and paranoia - makes him one of the most complex figures in Tanach. Rabbi Wein cites a variety of commentaries regarding Shaul Hamelech, from those which sing his praises to those which criticize him roundly. In reconciling these apparent contradictions, he gives a fascinating dissection of the character and reign of the first Jewish king.